Creepy as they get (Part 10) CreepyPasta x Reader

Jeff finishes his coffee hastily, then turns to you. "Ney _____, why don't I give you a tour of the place inside and out!" Jeff says with a smirk, you shake your head. "No, thanks I already kind of looked around." you reply, not feeling safe to explore with him; especially after that one comment. "So? It’s not like you saw everything anyway! Let's go!" He says sternly, grabbing your hand and forcing you to your feet. He quickly pulls you along the halls, not letting you protest.

"I'm pretty sure you get the idea that upstairs are for The Slender Family and… ummm… henchmen like you." he says, smiling even wider with his Cheshire like grin. "The hall under the stairs are our rooms, and Smexy's for a number of things." he continues, kind of frown when mentioning Smexy then flinches and checks around us like a spaz.

"Umm you ok?" you ask cautiously, as he grips your hand tighter. "Hmmm? Oh yeah, just… watching for any sudden movements is all." he replies then with a smile, starts pulling you to another room. "Here's a kitchen, and dining room, a closet, oh and in the closet is this tinier room. I don’t think much people know about it… well now you know about it. Keep it a secret." he says, placing a finger to his lips, pulling you over to the closet.

"Ok I will, but I'm not going in there.” you say pulling your hand free, feeling your face becoming warm. "Ok your loss, it has my collection of stuff anyway. Oh! I'll show you this place outside!" He says with an evil grin, and grabs your wrist, tugging you along again. "So there's not too much out here, in the woods that is, and I doubt that Slender is going to let you leave the woods just yet but there is this river it's pretty neat.”  He continues, just talking and talking away, not letting you speak once.

"Why am I letting him drag me along into the woods alone? I mean this dude is a known killer, who killed his own family without the least bit of regret." you think to yourself, but despite that you just let him anyway, doubt he’ll let you go either way.
You glance around the dusk kissed tree tops, the evergreens blowing in the wind softly. The trees look livelier than the nights before, yet still have a creepy vibe to them.  Jeff’s hand grips your wrist tightly, tugging you faster. Your thoughts drift back in fear, “What if his trying to get me far away from the house to….. Kill me.” the thought hits you, realizing this might be why he’s urging you to move faster. You have no idea what to do, your thoughts begin to race in panic. You tug your wrist, but only results in him pulling you harshly to keep up.  Your thoughts are broken up by the sound of running water.

You two get to an opening in the group of trees to see what seems odd for this dark, eerie woods, a beautiful river side with wild plants and flowers growing near it. It was like some kind of dream, you’re in awe to see this. "Wooow…." you whisper out, hearing Jeff laugh.  You blush, then remember he still had your wrist and you yank it away.

"I wasn't going to bite it off, anyway this is the only cool thing out here. I usually come here to wash up after a killing spree. Slender doesn't like his place messy, weird huh? I think its cause of his brothers." Jeff says, walking over to the water and kneeling down.

"This river is pretty nice looking, so is this area! It’s like a sanctuary almost. Good change of pace compared to everything in these woods." you say looking around, then paused. A thought popping into your mind, curious you decide to ask. "So…. what would happen if I just started running to leave..?" you stutter out, almost in a whisper.

Jeff stares at you, lifting an eyebrow, then chuckles. "Well, realistically, you would be wondering forever naturally. Without Slender's permission you are stuck to wonder in the endless woods, Or he would have you return to the mansion no matter how far you travel."  He says and picks up a rock and skips it across the water. “Or, if you’re asking what I would do, then that’s simple.” He grins, with a sinister chuckle then kneels down again. You feel shaken by his words, but you try to play it off and walk over to the water, Jeff quickly stands up.

"I won't get close right now." He says with no hint of joking. "Why?" you ask, scowling at him. "Ben still mad is all…." He says and shrugs, "Hey you know what! We should play a game! Like tag." He says with a smirk. "I rather not, chances are I'm going to end up with a knife into my back or something." You say quickly with a frown and backing away to the direction of the mansion. _{"Would not, I can play nice..."} Jeff whispers, and you just roll your eyes.

You walk back into the mansion, the light higher in the sky now.  You walk back into the mansion, to see Splendor in the kitchen making breakfast, along with Masky and Hoodie, "Good Morning _____!" Splendor says cheerfully, then frowns glancing at the mark on your flesh. "What's your favorite breakfast food?" he asks retuning his smile to his face. "Well… I do like ____(f/food)____." You say, and he smiles and nods, he starts gathering the ingredients. You look over the kitchen and see that someone is already in the dining room, enjoying a cup of coffee and reading a newspaper.

You walk over to the table, and sit down on one of the corner chairs, the person looks away from his paper. "Hey." Eyeless Jack says, then goes back to his paper, "how can he read without eyes" you think to yourself with a scowl of confusion, then something on the front of the newspaper catches your attention. You spot on the front page your photo and the words "missing". "Hey, I- can I see that?" you ask Jack, "Hmmm oh, the front story sure I guess, though it's just talking about your disappearance."

You quickly scan through the article, its mentions that they fear the worse. They found your room in dismay, and a lot of blood found at the crime scene. "My room was trashed?" you say out loud without thinking, staring at your photo in the paper. "Yeah, we had too. We had to make it more believable that you disappeared after all. Oh, and I saw your sketches of us. Don't worry no one else saw." Jack says with a calm voice, and your eyes go wide. "Wait, which ones did he see?!" you say to yourself then felt you face get flush.

You can hear Jeff in the kitchen with the others, from the sounds of it Jeff and Hoodie are in a heated debate over something. You just ignored them, not really interested in what those two are saying.  Your thoughts are cut off by a pair of arms wrapping around you, with a rose being held in front of your face.

"C-can I help you?" you say with a frown, knowing who it was already; his touch causing your mark to burn in pain. "Nope ~ <3 Just wanted to give you a rose, though it doesn't seem to sure pass your beauty, but I hope it its perfect enough for you."  He whispers in your ear, keeping his arms wrapped around you.

"Smexy… Do I need to eradicate another rose of yours?" Jack growls, standing to his feet, reaching one of his hands into his pocket. "Jack, why do you ruin the fun? Is it cause you're jealous? I have a rose just for you too you know." Smexy says, letting go of you, giving Jack a wink gesture. "No, I'm not jealous." He says, and shakes his head.

Smexy just shrugs, he goes to leave, but pauses. He grins, and leans back down. “I see my brother get his hands on you, looks painful….” he whispers softly and seductively. “I can fix that…”  he finishes, his words lingering on his tongue. You remain quiet, refusing to reply, your face feeling warm. You feel him grab your neck and shoulder, before you can protect, you feel his tongue slide across your mark. The sensation of both pain and soothing mix together, then suddenly the pain vanishes, like it was never there to begin with. Jack growls, and Smexy releases you with a chuckle and goes into the kitchen, a few seconds later you hear Jeff screaming and running out of the kitchen, followed with coos from Smexy.

"That asshole, thinks he can just have everyone he wants." Jack mutters, and goes back to his paper. You shutter, your mark feeling 100xs better but also feeling bothered by the feeling of his tongue on you.  You turn your focus back to the paper, trying to ignore what happened. Something in the paper, catches your attention, a quote from your best friend. It reads “I don’t know how this happened. I think it has something to do with these pictures ____ sent me, but I don’t know if ___’s ok or not.” You freeze fearing, the mere mention of the photos might cause a change of mind on whether they stay alive or not. You decide to stay quiet, hoping this doesn’t blow up.

  Within the next 10 minutes the dining room, became noisy with a bunch of its residents, you’re shocked they get along so well. Ben had shown up for food, but ignored you the whole time and Slender, well, he never even showed up at all.

You finish your breakfast, and so you decide to walk around the house again, and ending up near the bedrooms on the first floor. You walk by a door only to see a shirtless Jack, You unintentionally stop for a second before you realize you had started staring. "I got syrup on me." His voice comes in, as get grabs another shirt.  _{"Oh shit."} you whisper, "Sorry I didn't mean to stare."  you scrabble out, turning away.

"It's cool, did you need something?" he asks, walking out with a new hoodie on. "Oh ummm, not really just wondering around…" you trail off, feeling flushed. "Well you know, actually I was curious why Slender didn't show up…." you ask suddenly, and look over to Jack. "Oh, well, he always gets sick when he uses his powers to erase or steal memories, he says it's like taking all of their memories and slowly walking through their life tell he finds what he needs. I guess that's why he doesn't do it that often. I hear he turns more beastly when he does. Or rather blood thirsty." Jack explains walking over to the living room area, with you following right behind.

"Oh….." You say, your voice lowering. “Does that mean he knows more about my past then I remember?” you think to yourself, your thoughts drifting about. "You know, ignoring the fact that you are a human with kidneys and such, you're pretty cute." Jack says, looking over his shoulder. You blush, stopping in your tracks, "Wh-where did that come from?" you stutter out. "hmmm? Where did what come from?" he asks, and lays down onto the couch.